Declining migrants

Many of the summer migrants that come to the UK from Africa to breed are in decline, including Nightingale, Cuckoo and Swift. Our research uses long-term monitoring data alongside cutting edge tracking technology and field studies in Africa to understand the causes of these declines. The ultimate aim is to identify actions that may help to increase migrant populations, as well as to connect people to these species whilst there is still time.

Nightingale. Chris Knights

Declines of Afro-Palaearctic migrants

Breeding populations of Afro-Palaearctic migrants (those species which travel from tropical Africa to breed each spring) are falling not only in the UK, but across Europe. Some of our best-known and loved migratory species have undergone the steepest declines, including Swift, Nightingale, Cuckoo, House Martin and Spotted Flycatcher. From the late 1960s to the mid 1980s, species that winter in the Sahel - the arid zone immediately south of the Sahara desert - underwent severe declines. These included Whitethroat, Sand Martin and Sedge Warbler, and BTO research demonstrated that they were being affected by a prolonged drought in that region of Africa. More recently, however, our research has shown that those species currently in decline are mostly those that winter further south, in the humid tropics of West and Central Africa or in Southern Africa. The reasons for these declines are as-yet unclear and much recent BTO research has been directed towards trying to understand them.

Some of our best-known and loved migratory species have undergone the steepest declines, including Swift, Nightingale, Cuckoo, House Martin and Spotted Flycatcher.  

Complex causes

The causes of these declines are likely to be complicated. Many of these species occupy complex habitats such as woodland whilst they are breeding and they may be impacted by processes occurring anywhere in their annual cycle. They might use several sites separated by thousands of kilometers through the year and the processes driving declines may occur at several of these, and there may be interactions between events occurring at different stages.

Until recently we lacked even a basic understanding of how most of these birds spent the majority of the year when they are not with us. That is now changing due to the miniaturisation of tracking devices, but even for those species we now know the most about, there is still much to learn about their annual cycles and how different events affect breeding populations.

cuckoo migration routes
Cuckoo migration routes. Infographic by Nigel Hawtin

Tracking migrations

The miniaturisation of tracking devices has revolutionised our knowledge of the annual cycles of Afro-Palaearctic migrants. We have been able to track Cuckoos with satellite transmitters, teaching us not only where these birds go, but also where they die. This research showed that the birds take one of two routes to reach Africa, travelling either via Italy or via Spain, and that fewer of the birds travelling via Spain survived to reach tropical Africa. The proportion of birds from different parts of the country that took the more hazardous route via Spain correlated with the degree of local population decline, suggesting that it was linked with this mortality on migration. How this link works, however, is subject to ongoing research aiming to determine the relative impact of conditions in the UK versus those in southern Europe and how this might differ between birds using each route.

Many of our smaller migrants can now be tracked with geolocators, which are small data loggers that record light intensity against time. They allow migrations to be reconstructed, from daylength and the timing of solar midday. These devices were first used to track the migrations of albatrosses, but as they became miniaturised the BTO began to use them, initially on Swifts and Nightingales. The smallest now weigh only a third of a gram and we have used them on species several species including Nightingales, Whinchats, Tree Pipits, Spotted Flycatchers and even Willow and Wood Warblers.  

Cuckoo. Charles Tyler

Breeding grounds - insect declines, climate change and habitat loss

There have been huge changes to the UK environment in recent decades. These are likely to have impacted populations of Afro-Palaearctic migrants. It is difficult to imagine that they have not been affected by the huge recent declines of insect populations across Europe, given that most have evolved to exploit this once superabundant resource of the northern summer. So far, however, it is not clear to what extent declines have been driven by these changes versus those occurring in the other places migrants use through their annual cycle. This may also differ between species.

Food availability may be waning for a number of reasons. Climate change has lead to hotter, drier summers which may be directly contributing to insect declines in some habitats. Warmer and earlier springs may cause migrants, especially those that have not advanced their spring arrival to the UK, to miss the seasonal peaks of insect abundance that they depend on for breeding. These effects may either directly impact breeding success or subsequently reduce survival of birds that have had to work harder to raise their young. Other factors that may contribute to reductions in food availability include the application of agricultural chemicals and removal of insects’ habitat.

The availability of high-quality habitat has also probably greatly diminished for some bird species, particularly those occupying scrub and dense undergrowth in woodland such as the Nightingale. This is as a result of changes in woodland management, increasingly intense deer browsing and clearing of patches of scrub. These habitats are poorly monitored, however, so it is not easy assess the extent of this change and its impacts.

BTO's research approach, monitoring migrant populations across years and following individuals throughout their annual cycles, will continue to improve our understanding of why so many migrant birds are declining, and should ultimately inform effective conservation action to reverse these population trends, so we can continue to welcome our summer visitors for generations to come.

Support migrant research

Learn about our Cuckoo Tracking Project, and consider becoming a sponsor.

Donate to our Spotted Flycatcher Appeal to help us understand the reasons why this much-loved migrant is declining.

Donate to Spotted Flycatcher Appeal

Related Publications

Peer-reviewed papers
Spotted Flycatcher. Photograph by Jonathan Tyler

Declines in Afro-Palearctic migrant birds are linked to bioclimatic wintering zone, possibly via constraints in arrival time advancement

Migrant declines linked to wintering grounds

2012 | Ockendon, N.O., Hewson, C.M., Johnston, A. & Atkinson, P.W.

Bird Study

More Details
Peer-reviewed papers
Cuckoo by Edmund Fellowes

Population decline is linked to migration route in the Common Cuckoo, a long-distance nocturnally-migrating bird

Cuckoo declines linked to different migration routes to Africa

2016 | Hewson, C.M., Thorup, K., Pearce-Higgins, J.W. & Atkinson, P.W.

Nature Communications

More Details
Peer-reviewed papers
Willow Warbler

The sensitivity of breeding songbirds to change in seasonal timing is linked to population change but cannot be directly attributed to the effects of trophic asynchrony on productivity. 

Does the early bird catch the caterpillar?

2017 | Franks, S.E., Pearce-Higgins, J.W., Atkinson, S., Bell, J.R., Botham, M.S., Brereton, T.M., Harrington, R. & Leech, D.I.

Global Change Biology

More Details
Peer-reviewed papers
Swallow by Amy Lewis

Long-term changes in the migration phenology of UK breeding birds detected by large-scale citizen science recording schemes

Summer migrants stay for longer as the UK climate warms

2016 | Newson, S.E., Moran, N.J., Musgrove, A.J., Pearce-Higgins, J.W., Gillings, S., Atkinson, P.W., Miller, R., Grantham, M.J. & Baillie, S.R.

Ibis

More Details


Related content