Latitudinal gradients in the productivity of European migrant warblers have not shifted northwards during a period of climate change
Author(s): Eglington, S. M., Julliard, R., Gargallo, G., van der Jeugd, H. P., Pearce-Higgins, J. W., Baillie, S. R. and Robinson, R. A.
Published: January 2015
Journal: Global Ecology and Biogeography Volume: 24
Digital Identifier No. (DOI): 10.1111/geb.12267View publication
A long-term monitoring study involving bird ringers from five countries has investigated how changes in the reproductive output of seven species of migrant warbler vary with latitude and spring temperature. The implications for predicted changes in species distribution are also discussed.
One of the most notable signatures of climate change is the shift in species distributions towards the poles with rising temperatures, but the mechanisms underlying this change are not well understood. Most research to date has focused on individual study areas, rather than looking across the wider range occupied by the species under study. One possible mechanism for the observed distribution shifts is changes in the patterns of productivity (i.e. the number of juveniles raised per adult). Productivity within the migrant songbirds breeding in Europe might be expected to vary with latitude, underpinned by the effects of temperature and day length on plant and invertebrate production. If thermal isoclines (areas of equal temperature) are shifting northwards in Europe, then we might expect to see similar shifts in patterns of songbird productivity.
Bird ringing and productivity estimates
European-scale measures of songbird productivity are available from the standardized bird ringing projects operated as part of the EuroCES programme. This study, led by the BTO and involving colleagues from partner organisations elsewhere in Europe, collated more than two decades of capture data for 350,000 individual birds of seven migrant warbler species (Chiffchaff, Willow Warbler, Sedge Warbler, Reed Warbler, Whitethroat, Blackcap and Garden Warbler) from 426 individual CES (Constant Effort Sites) sites operated in England, Ireland, France, Catalonia and the Netherlands. The results demonstrated that ringers whose sites are located at intermediate latitudes (approximately in the middle of a species' breeding range) tended to catch the highest proportion of juveniles, which is used as a proxy of productivity. These patterns have generally not shifted poleward through time, providing limited evidence to support the prediction that recent warming has led to an increase in productivity at the northern margins of species ranges, as suggested by previous studies of distribution and community change.
"Average" springs are good for breeding
The key finding of the study was that species generally appeared to be adapted to local conditions, producing most chicks in “average” years; when temperatures were cooler or warmer than average, productivity fell. While the mechanism by which spring temperatures influence productivity cannot be inferred, it seems plausible that the availability of invertebrate food is likely to be important. This suggests that, despite the observed relationships between productivity and temperature, the implications for distributional shift are unclear at this stage. Other factors, notably habitat quality and wider resource availability, may be important because local adaptation to these may constrain species responses to a changing climate. Other work by BTO has shown that population increases may be facilitated more by changes in survival, although how this might affect distribution is less clear (Robinson et al. 2014). Collectively these studies highlight that in order to be able to determine the effect of climate change on birds, continent-wide monitoring of abundance, productivity and survival is vital. Without such information, it will be impossible to effectively manage populations in such a way to help species adapt to climate change effects.
Tritrophic phenological match-mismatch in space and time.
The increasing temperatures associated with a changing climate may disrupt ecological systems, including by affecting the timing of key events. If events within different trophic levels are affected...
Using data from schools to model variation in soil invertebrates across the UK: The importance of weather, climate, season and habitat
A new study, supported by EDF Energy and BTO, has looked into soil invertebrate communities in the UK using large-scale citizen science data from schools.
Can climate matching predict the current and future climatic suitability of the UK for the establishment of non-native birds?
Non-native species are becoming a more common sight, but is this linked to the changing climate? A new BTO study investigates whether it's possible to predict which non-native species are likely...