Collation of a century of soil invertebrate abundance data suggests long-term declines in earthworms but not tipulids
Author(s): Barnes, A.E., Robinson, R.A. & Pearce-Higgins, J.W.
Published: February 2023
Journal: PLOS ONE
Digital Identifier No. (DOI): 10.1371/journal.pone.0282069
Large-scale declines in insect populations have attracted much interest, prompting use of the term ‘insectaggedon’. However, a lack of robust monitoring data means that much uncertainty remains, both in our understanding of the scale of declines and how these may differ between insect groups. We know even less about the changing fortunes of other invertebrates, such as earthworms, despite their vital role in ecosystem functioning.
This paper uses historical UK datasets, derived from previously published research, in an attempt to assess if there have been long-term changes in earthworm abundance. A literature review identified over 100 studies, covering the best part of a century, from which it was possible to extract abundance data. The researchers accounted for differences in the methods used across the studies, and examined both changes over time and differences between habitats.
The results were consistent with there having been long-term declines in earthworm abundance, ranging from 1.6% to 2.1% per year in magnitude. These figures equate to a 33% to 41% decline over a 25-year period – 25 years being a standard measure for assessing conservation status based on measures of abundance change.
Habitat-specific analyses suggest that the declines in earthworm abundance have been greatest in broad-leaved woodland than in other habitats. Within farmland, the declines were greater in pasture rather than in arable landscapes as anticipated.
The reasons for the observed declines are not investigated in the paper, but could be linked to climate change and shifts in agricultural practices. Earthworms are sensitive to soil moisture levels, so a warming climate and the land drainage could see soils dry out, making them less suitable for earthworms. Other possible drivers could include pollution and agricultural run-off, together with the mechanical impacts of ploughing and other forms of cultivation.
These results do not come from a structured, designed monitoring scheme like the BTO/JNCC/RSPB Breeding Bird Survey, but a collation of data from previous studies. Given what they suggest could be occurring beneath our feet, which would be a significant conservation and economic issue in the UK, this study emphasises the urgent need for robust long-term monitoring of key invertebrate groups.
NotesThe authors are extremely grateful to the many BTO donors and members who have funded this project, particularly Simon Cooke and Gillian & Justin Wills and the Penchant Foundation. They are also grateful to Kenneth Trouth whose Gift in Will supported the work on this paper. They would like to acknowledge the help of UEA Master’s students Rhianna Wren, Evan Burdett, Abigail Hunns and Ashis Datta who assisted with the review and identification of relevant papers.
Are the declines of birds and invertebrates linked by climate change?
Many of the detected effects of climate change on biodiversity have occurred through impacts on food chains.
The latest bird indicators provide a useful summary of how the fortunes of birds have fared in different landscapes across the UK and England, and Scotland.