Designing effective survey and sampling protocols for passive acoustic monitoring as part of the national bat monitoring
Author(s): Newson, S.E., Boughey, K.L., Robinson, R.A & Gillings, S.
Published: June 2021
Journal: JNCC Report Volume: 688View publication
The UK has one of the best developed bat monitoring programmes in the world, but despite this, six of 17 resident bat species in the UK are not currently monitored sufficiently to produce population trends. Large-scale deployment of passive acoustic methods using full spectrum bat detector technology offers a lot of potential for transforming routine monitoring of bat numbers, but it is essential that effective survey and sampling protocols are used if this potential is to be realised.
To guide these decisions, we analyse passive acoustic data collected by volunteers from a study area in south-west Britain to quantify the ability and power to detect population declines in bat numbers in relation to: i) whether recording is carried out across the whole night, ii) whether a record / sleep cycle is used, and iii) the number of sites surveyed.
Our results indicate that recording should be carried out over the full night to avoid producing biased estimates of decline. If recording is carried out according to a record / sleep cycle, then the sleep time should be short so that any biases, and reductions in precision and power to detect declines are small. A national scheme should aim to record target bat species on a much larger number of sites than considered in this study. This is likely to require stratification (e.g. by region and/or habitat), to maximise the number of sites that record the most range-restricted species to be able to produce trends for these.
NotesWe are very grateful to the Bat Conservation Trust for providing the bat data used here. These data were collected to inform the design of the British Bat Survey (BBatS). BBatS will be run by the Bat Conservation Trust as part of the National Bat Monitoring Programme (NBMP), which is carried out in partnership with the Joint Nature Conservation Committee, and supported and steered by Natural England, Natural Resources Wales, Northern Ireland Environment Agency, and NatureScot. The NBMP is indebted to the volunteers who contributed data. We are also extremely grateful to Steve Langton for commenting on an earlier draft of the report, and to Julie Day and Niki Newton from the Joint Nature Conservation Committee (JNCC) for their support and input to the development of this work. These analyses were funded by JNCC, as part of the Terrestrial Surveillance Development and Analysis (TSDA) partnership.
Making the most of BirdTrack data
We have been working to produce useful summaries for bird reports using data from the millions of annual BirdTrack records.
BTO Conference 2021
Catch-up on a series of fascinating free online talks and panels celebrating the efforts of BTO volunteers and scientists.