Wider Countryside Report Header
BTO Blueline
Main WCR menu image Site navigation menu item Results overview menu item Other info menu item BTO website menu item
BTO Blueline
BBWC Home > Contents > Discussion > Ten-year trends and evidence for species recovery
4.3 Ten-year trends and evidence for species recovery

 

If the status of species that have shown long-term declines were now improving, we would expect to find trends to be more positive in recent years compared with the earlier part of the time series. To examine this, we list in Table 4.3.1 the best change estimates over the most recent ten-year period for which we have data (1996–2006) for all of the declining species listed in the previous section of this report (section 4.2). The table also includes four species, Wood Warbler (amber), Red Grouse (amber), Grasshopper Warbler (red) and Snipe (amber) for which we can report ten-year trends but lack reliable data covering longer periods.

 
Table 4.3.1 Ten year trends for species that have shown long-term declines

Species Period
(yrs)
Source Change
(%)
Lower
limit
Upper
limit
Alert Comment
Willow Tit 10 CBC/BBS UK -64 -72 -51 >50  
Turtle Dove 10 CBC/BBS UK -58 -62 -51 >50  
Wood Warbler 10 BBS UK -53 -67 -36 >50  
Lesser Spotted Woodpecker 10 CBC to 1999 -51 -75 -22 >50 Small sample
Cuckoo 10 CBC/BBS England -46 -49 -43 >25  
Yellow Wagtail 10 CBC/BBS UK -42 -53 -31 >25  
Woodcock 10 CBC to 1999 -40 -62 -11 >25 Small sample
Grey Partridge 10 CBC/BBS UK -39 -48 -31 >25  
Starling 10 CBC/BBS England -36 -39 -32 >25  
Lesser Redpoll 10 CBC/BBS England -33 -51 13    
Redshank 10 WBS waterways -33 -51 -12 >25 Small sample
Spotted Flycatcher 10 CBC/BBS UK -32 -38 -16 >25  
Little Grebe 10 WBS waterways -30 -72 22   Small sample
Tree Pipit 10 CBC/BBS England -30 -47 -7 >25  
Willow Warbler 10 CBC/BBS England -30 -36 -24 >25  
Corn Bunting 10 CBC/BBS UK -27 -38 -15 >25  
Linnet 10 CBC/BBS England -27 -32 -21 >25  
Reed Warbler 10 CES adults -26 -36 -13 >25  
Little Owl 10 CBC/BBS UK -20 -33 -7    
Red Grouse 10 BBS UK -20 -31 -7    
Curlew 10 CBC/BBS England -19 -26 -12    
Marsh Tit 10 CBC/BBS UK -16 -28 -2    
Tawny Owl 10 CBC/BBS UK -15 -29 5    
House Sparrow 10 CBC/BBS England -13 -18 -7    
Skylark 10 CBC/BBS England -13 -17 -9    
Lapwing 10 CBC/BBS UK -12 -23 -3    
Bullfinch 10 CBC/BBS UK -11 -17 -3    
Common Sandpiper 10 WBS waterways -11 -28 5    
Yellowhammer 10 CBC/BBS UK -11 -15 -5    
Grasshopper Warbler 10 BBS UK -6 -32 13    
Mistle Thrush 10 CBC/BBS UK -6 -11 2    
Meadow Pipit 10 CBC/BBS England -5 -15 6    
Sedge Warbler 10 CBC/BBS UK -3 -18 11    
House Martin 10 CBC/BBS England 5 -4 14    
Kestrel 10 CBC/BBS England 5 -2 14    
Whitethroat 10 CBC/BBS UK 14 7 20    
Goldcrest 10 CBC/BBS England 22 11 35    
Dunnock 10 CBC/BBS UK 23 18 28    
Song Thrush 10 CBC/BBS UK 23 17 29    
Tree Sparrow 10 CBC/BBS England 24 7 54    
Snipe 10 BBS UK 29 14 47    
Reed Bunting 10 CBC/BBS UK 30 19 44    
Grey Wagtail 10 WBS waterways 32 14 48    

See PSoB pages for information on red and amber criteria
 

The 43 species listed include 17 from the red list, 18 declining species that are amber listed on account of population declines and eight species that are not formally listed as declining. The eight species include Curlew which is already amber listed for reasons concerned with its European status.

Eight species at the foot of the table, Grey Wagtail, Reed Bunting, Snipe, Tree Sparrow, Song Thrush, Dunnock, Goldcrest and Whitethroat, show clear positive trends over the last ten years. The increases in the red-listed Reed Bunting and Song Thrush are particularly encouraging, as are the positive trends for the amber-listed Grey Wagtail and Dunnock. However, the most recent figures for Song Thrush and Grey Wagtail suggest that their recoveries may be levelling off well short of their previous population levels. Similarly while the BBS shows a 29% increase in Snipe over the last ten years, much of the former range across lowland Britain lost since the 1960s remains unoccupied, and moreover the population has been declining again since 2003. Whitethroat numbers have increased steadily since the mid 1980s but are still far below the population level prior to the 1968/69 crash. The increase in Tree Sparrow numbers is very welcome but is coming from such a low level that numbers remain far below those of the mid 1970s, with the population trend graph still showing little sign of a clear recovery.

 

The rate of decline of 25% over 25 years that is used as a threshold for amber listing is equivalent to a decline of 10.9% over ten years (assuming constant annual rates of change). A further nine species, Yellowhammer, Sedge Warbler, Common Sandpiper, Meadow Pipit, Bullfinch, Mistle Thrush, Kestrel, Grasshopper Warbler and House Martin have population changes of between +11% and -11% over the last ten years. Where these changes are not statistically significant (eight species), these populations are best regarded as stable. Thus our data suggest that the declines of these species appear to be levelling off, although on this time scale there is as yet no indication of recovery. The position of Yellowhammer, with a significant decrease of 11%, is less certain.

 

Ten-year changes for the remaining 26 species in Table 4.3.1 indicate ongoing declines, with rates equivalent to at least 25% over 25 years. Four species, Willow Tit, Turtle Dove, Wood Warbler and Lesser Spotted Woodpecker, have declined by more than 50% over the last ten years alone. For Lesser Spotted Woodpecker, the ten years in question are 1989–99, since when the species has become too scarce for BBS to monitor. A further 12 species have declined by more than 25% over the last ten years alone. The ongoing declines of so many of the species listed in Table 4.3.1 must be a cause of serious conservation concern.

 

Return to previous page

Next page – 4.4 Increasing species

BTO blue divider
 

BTO Home | JNCC Home
 © British Trust for Ornithology. Charity No 216652 (England and Wales).Charity No SC039193 (Scotland)
Company Limited by Guarantee No 357284 (England and Wales).
Registered Office: The Nunnery, Thetford, Norfolk IP24 2PU, UK.
Terms and Conditions
| Privacy Statement          Email:


This report should be cited as:
Baillie, S.R., Marchant, J.H., Leech, D.I., Joys, A.C., Noble, D.G.,
Barimore, C., Grantham, M.J., Risely, K. & Robinson, R.A. (2009).
Breeding Birds in the Wider Countryside: their conservation status 2008.
BTO Research Report No. 516. BTO, Thetford. (http://www.bto.org/birdtrends)

Pages maintained by Iain Downie, Mandy T Andrews and Laura Smith: Last updated 02.04.2009